Every few months, Mr. Lukas Foljanty puts together a comprehensive report for the on-demand transportation community. In his latest reports, Lukas has introduced a compelling new concept for evaluating the on-demand transport industry: productivity.
He defines productivity with the following formula:
This metric serves as a proxy for assessing benefit versus cost.
Since fares and vehicle/labour costs can vary between cities, measuring productivity in terms of PAX/VRH allows for meaningful comparisons of transport services, whether fixed routes or on-demand.
Shotl have been calculating its productivity using this metric as one of the indicators. Results show that more than half of our running operations have a PAX/VRH value of 5 or more, which represents the top 10% of the operations. Among them, three of our current operations demonstrate notably high productivity values that consistently reach 10+ PAX/VRH, and have even seen weekly mean records above 15.
The key factors contributing to this high productivity are both endogenous and exogenous to the Shotl platform. Firstly, Shotl has a variety of different metric goals to optimize routes, for total time, punctuality, vehicle efficiency, etc, with several parameters that allow for +40 combinations. In high-demand environments, vehicle efficiency-related metrics seem to bring the best results.
Furthermore, it seems that factors related to the area design, such as the average trip duration and the ability to consolidate passengers travelling in similar directions, are key for achieving good productivity. In one of its very high PAX/VRH cases, the service area is quite compact, with average trip lengths of around 6 minutes. The hilly terrain discourages walking, making the DRT service a convenient alternative. Additionally, most passengers travel between specific areas A and B, which simplifies matching passenger routes. The availability of multiple stops in these areas provides enough demand to make an on-demand service valuable and not easily replaceable by a fixed bus line.
In another case, the service operates in a larger area but also with a larger fleet. The key to this success seems to be high vehicle density. With a vehicle available roughly every 2 square kilometres, it becomes easier to match passengers travelling in similar directions, thus enhancing the overall service quality.
Based on these findings, we recommend four strategies for successful on-demand transport operations:
By adopting these strategies, you can enhance the productivity and success of on-demand transport services.
28.12.20
At Shotl, we’re often asked what the greatest challenges are in getting people to accept our model of flexible, demand-responsive transit. The answer may surprise you.
24.06.19
Pollution, congestion and changing mobility are challenging the car’s dominion over cities. Amsterdam is the latest taking bold steps to reclaim the streets for people, with potentially huge benefits.
30.08.21
In July 2021, our Co-founder and CEO, Gerard Martret, attended the annual conference of the Fédération Internationale de l'Automobile (FIA).